Labour Party's Business Tax Policy: A Path to Economic Management

The state of public finances presents a significant challenge for any government, especially when pressured to increase public spending. The Labour Party, in particular, faces the task of managing the economy while pacifying concerns about...

The state of public finances presents a significant challenge for any government, especially when pressured to increase public spending. The Labour Party, in particular, faces the task of managing the economy while pacifying concerns about their ability to do so effectively. To address this challenge, the party has taken a disciplined approach, backing up their spending commitments with costed tax measures that demonstrate fiscal responsibility. However, the question remains whether additional tax rises will be necessary to balance the books and meet spending demands once in office.

Carried Interest - Closing the Loophole or Pursuing Reform?

At the heart of the Labour Party's business tax policies is the issue of carried interest. Rachel Reeves, in her 2021 party conference, launched the start of the party's carried interest campaign. The aim is to treat "bonuses of private equity bosses as income rather than capital gains." This policy is not only about fairness but also tied to a promise to fund the recruitment of thousands of new mental health professionals.

Carried Interest Caption: Labour Party's campaign to treat bonuses of private equity bosses as income rather than capital gains.

While the full details of the policy have not yet been articulated, taxing carried interest as earned income instead of a capital gain would raise the headline rate from 28% to 47% (including NICs). This could make the UK significantly uncompetitive compared to other jurisdictions. Rather than abolishing the regime entirely, the Labour Party could consider reforming it. Many European countries have implemented more targeted approaches with specific conditions, such as holding periods, co-investment requirements, or taxing a portion of carried interest as remuneration. France, for example, applies a slightly higher rate (34%) but still lower than its general earned income tax rate.

Carried Interest Caption: Reforming the carried interest regime could reduce the competitive disadvantage faced by the UK.

The impact of abolishing the carried interest regime on tax revenue is subject to debate. Estimates suggest that increasing the carried interest rate to 47% without considering any behavioral response could raise tax revenues by around £646m per year. However, it is important to account for the potential migration of individuals and the subsequent dynamic effect on revenue. Unpublished HM Treasury analysis even suggests that abolishing the regime could cost the Exchequer £350m per year. Reforming the regime, rather than eliminating it, might offer a safer route to raising revenue.

Review of the UK Business Tax Regime

Rachel Reeves has committed the Labour Party to conduct a comprehensive review of the UK business tax system. The aim is to provide more certainty and boost investment. While it is unclear whether the results of this review will be published before the general election, it will culminate in the party publishing a roadmap that will guide policy over the parliamentary term. The review will consider tax reliefs, with reports suggesting that £4bn worth of reliefs are under threat. Additionally, the party aims to target share buybacks and dividend payments to encourage reinvestment of profits in businesses and investment allowances.

The Labour Party's business tax policies aim to strike a balance between economic management, fairness, and investment. However, the true impact of these policies remains uncertain. As the election approaches and the new government takes office, it will be interesting to see how these policies are implemented and whether they effectively meet the challenges of managing the economy and balancing the books.

Please note that this article is based on the Labour Party's announced business tax policies, and the details may be subject to change.

1